Is lazy loading in linux possible? [duplicate] - c++

Question

I've been searching a way to make a shared library (let's name the library libbar.so) delay loaded on Linux and it should hopefully be realized with a help from only a linker, not modifying anything on the source code written in C++; I mean I don't want to invoke dlopen() nor dlsym() in the source code of the parent library (let's name it libfoo.so) to invoke a function of libbar.so because they make the source code messy and the maintenance process difficult. (In short, I'm expecting to go on the similar way to Visual Studio's /DELAYLOAD option even on Linux)
Anyway, I've found some uncertain information pieces related to my question on the internet so far, so it would be very nice to have the answers from you all for the following questions to make the information clear.
Does GNU ld support any delay loading mechanism on Linux?
If it doesn't, how about Clang?
Is the dlopen() family the only way to make a shared library delay loaded on Linux?
I tested to pass -zlazy flag to GCC (g++) with a path to the library, it seemed to accept the flag but the behavior did not look making libbar.so delay loaded (Not having libbar.so, I was expecting to have an exception at the first call of libbar.so, but the exception actually raised before entering to libfoo.so). On the other hand, Clang (clang++) left a warning that it ignored the option flag.
Best regards,

Answer 1

Delay loading is NOT a runtime feature. MSVC++ implemented it without help from Windows. And like dlopen is the only way on Linux, GetProcAddress is the only runtime method on Windows.
So, what is delay loading then? It's very simple: Any call to a DLL has to go through a pointer (since you don't know where it will load). This has always been handled by the compiler and linker for you. But with delay loading, MSVC++ sets this pointer initially to a stub that calls LoadLibrary and GetProcAddress for you.
Clang can do the same without help from ld. At runtime, it's just an ordinary dlopen call, and Linux cannot determine that Clang inserted it.

Answer 2

This functionality can be achieved in a portable way using Proxy design pattern.
In code it may look something like this:
#include <memory>
// SharedLibraryProxy.h
struct SharedLibraryProxy
{
virtual ~SharedLibraryProxy() = 0;
// Shared library interface begin.
virtual void foo() = 0;
virtual void bar() = 0;
// Shared library interface end.
static std::unique_ptr<SharedLibraryProxy> create();
};
// SharedLibraryProxy.cc
struct SharedLibraryProxyImp : SharedLibraryProxy
{
void* shared_lib_ = nullptr;
void (*foo_)() = nullptr;
void (*bar_)() = nullptr;
SharedLibraryProxyImp& load() {
// Platform-specific bit to load the shared library at run-time.
if(!shared_lib_) {
// shared_lib_ = dlopen(...);
// foo_ = dlsym(...)
// bar_ = dlsym(...)
}
return *this;
}
void foo() override {
return this->load().foo_();
}
void bar() override {
return this->load().bar_();
}
};
SharedLibraryProxy::~SharedLibraryProxy() {}
std::unique_ptr<SharedLibraryProxy> SharedLibraryProxy::create() {
return std::unique_ptr<SharedLibraryProxy>{new SharedLibraryProxyImp};
}
// main.cc
int main() {
auto shared_lib = SharedLibraryProxy::create();
shared_lib->foo();
shared_lib->bar();
}

Answer 3

To add to MSalters answer, one can easily mimic Windows approach to lazy loading on Linux by creating a small static stub library that would try to dlopen needed library on first call to any of it's functions (emitting diagnostic message and terminating if dlopen failed) and then forwarding all calls to it.
Such stub libraries can be written by hand, generated by project/library-specific script or generated by universal tool Implib.so:
$ implib-gen.py libxyz.so
$ gcc myapp.c libxyz.tramp.S libxyz.init.c ...