Using these two formulas in Google Sheets results in different output results.
The IF result will expand the array across the cells as expected.
The IFS result only displays the first array value.
=IF(1=1,{1,2,3}) RESULT: 1 2 3 (across three cells)
=IFS(1=1,{1,2,3}) RESULT: 1 (in one cell)
Can someone explain why these results differ?
You may think that behaviour of IFS() is similar to IF() and reason of having IFS() is to avoid nesting of multiple IF() but that's not so true. Yes, there are some common baselines however, there is a major difference when it comes to arrays. IFS() in a combination of arrayed output expects arrayed input - that's why you got returned single-cell output instead of arrayed output.
let's say your IF() formula is like:
"converting" it into IFS() will return this (because cell A1 is not array/range):
now let's add a arrayformula (ranged input):
also note this behaviour:
Not at answer to why (IMO off topic) but to get the same result from IFS:
=IFS({1,1,1},{1,2,3})
Can be written:
=IFS({1=1,1=1,1=1},{1,2,3})
Related
I'm working on a sheet that can be extracted from a system and all the data is in one cell so i need to split them and it is basic for all cells except for resutls. as you can see test results should follow the same pattren of result status. so i regularlly splited one column (test status) and i tried to split test results based on if condition
it worked perfectly, however, for some status test results were not spliting because (Array arguments to IF are of different size.)
how do i fix this, please help
Thank you
Because IF() function is checking only first cell of C2:G2 range. Concat them into a single string them use search function to detect word Final. Try-
=IF(ISNUMBER(SEARCH("Final",JOIN(",",C2:G2))),SPLIT(H2,","),"")
You may try this:
=BYCOL(C2:G2,LAMBDA(Σ,(IF(Σ<>"Final",,INDEX(SPLIT(H2,","),, COUNTIF(C2:Σ,Σ))))))
enter image description here
I have a table in OpenOffice that contains a column with region's codes (column J). Using table functions, how to get all codes that appear more than 5 times and write them in one cell?
Normally I would recommend breaking this problem down into smaller parts using helper columns. Or better yet, move the data into LibreOffice Base which can easily work with distinct values.
However, I managed to come up with a rather large formula that seems to do what you asked. Enter it as an array formula.
=TEXTJOIN(",";1;IF(COUNTIF(исходник.J$2:J$552;исходник.J2:J552)>5;IF(ROW(исходник.J2:J552)=MATCH(исходник.J2:J552;исходник.J$2:J$552;0)+ROW(J$2)-1;исходник.J2:J552;"")))
I can't test this on your actual data since your example is only an image, but let's say that there are six of both 77 and 37. Then this would show 77,37 as the result.
Here is a breakdown. Look up the functions in LibreOffice Online Help for more information.
=TEXTJOIN(",";1; — Join all results into a single cell, separated by commas.
IF(COUNTIF(исходник.J$2:J$552;исходник.J2:J552)>5; — Find codes that occur more than 5 times. This is the same as what you wrote.
IF(ROW(исходник.J2:J552)= — Compare the next result to the row number that we are currently looking at.
MATCH(исходник.J2:J552;исходник.J$2:J$552;0)+ROW(J$2)-1; — Determine the first row that has this code. We do this to get unique results instead of 6 or more of each code in the result.
исходник.J2:J552;""))) — Return the code. (Your formula simply returns 1 here, which doesn't seem to be what you want.) If it doesn't match, return an empty string rather than 0, because TEXTJOIN ignores empty strings.
=COUNTIFS(Orders!$T:$T,$B4)
is a code that gives 0 or a +ve result
I use this across 1500 cells which makes the sheet gets filled with 0s
I'd like to remove the Zeros by using the following formula
if(COUNTIFS(Orders!$T:$T,$B3,Orders!$F:$F,""&P$1&"*")=0,
"",
COUNTIFS(Orders!$T:$T,$B3,Orders!$F:$F,""&P$1&"*"))
This calculates every formula twice and increases the calculation time.
How can we do this in 1 formula where if the value is 0 - keep empty - otherwise display the answer
I suggest this cell-function:
=IFERROR(1/(1/COUNTIFS(Orders!$T:$T,$B4)))
EDIT:
I'm not sure what to add as explanation. Basically to replace the result of a complex calculation with blank cells if it results in 0, you can wrap the complex function in
IFERROR(1/(1/ ComplexFunction() ))
It works by twice taking the inverse (1/X) of the result, thus returning the original result in all cases except 0 where a DIV0 error is generated. This error is then caught by IFERROR to result in a blank cell.
The advantage of this method is that it doesn't need to calculate the complex function twice, so can give a significant speed/readability increase, and doesn't fool the output like a custom number format which can be important if this cell is used in further functions.
You only need to set the number format for your range of cells.
Go to the menu Format-->Number-->More Formats-->Custom Number Format...
In the entry area at the top, enter the following: #;-#;""
The "format" of the format string is
(positive value format) ; (negative value format) ; (zero value format)
You can apply colors or commas or anything else. See this link for details
instead of your =COUNTIFS(Orders!$T:$T,$B4) use:
=REGEXREPLACE(""&COUNTIFS(Orders!$T:$T,$B4), "^0$", )
also, to speed up things you should avoid "per row formulae" and use ArrayFormulas
I can't find an example close enough to this one on StackOverflow so here goes:
I want to return a message "Type?" if cell X is blank and cell Y has any text. But I'm trying to nestle it into an existing set of IFs.
Existing :
=IF($G241="Evo";M241*L241;IF($G241="Free";M241*L241;IF($G241="GN";M241*L241))))
Nestling this into the above:
=IF(AND(NOT(ISBLANK($J234));ISBLANK(G234));"Type?";"OK")
I tried this but it returns FALSE, maybe due to the AND I'm using, which I need since I'm creating a return based on two cells two cells.
=IF($G240="Evo";M240*L240;IF(AND(NOT(ISBLANK($J240));ISBLANK(G240);"Type?";"OK");IF($G240="Free";M240*L240;IF($G240="GN";M240*L240))))
getting Error:
AND expects boolean values. But 'Type?' is a text and cannot be coerced to a boolean.
IF(and(isblank(cell x),iferror(isstring(cell y),false)),"Type?","OK")
That should do it for you I think. you will need to replace cell x and cell y with the appropriate references. The iferror statement is there to catch what happens when evaluating a blank cell y.
The problem with this formula
=IF($G240="Evo";M240*L240;IF(AND(NOT(ISBLANK($J240));ISBLANK(G240);"Type?";"OK");IF($G240="Free";M240*L240;IF($G240="GN";M240*L240))))
is you are trying to check G240 for different values when it cant. Lets simplify your formula. We will replace your empty cell check with FORMULA 1
=If($G240="EVO", Do True Condition, Do Formula 1, IF(G$240=Free, Do Free True Condition, Do Free False Condition)
The problem is since you already did something (Formula 1) when G240 = "EVO", you cant start another check on what G240 after the fact with the way you have embedded your formula. a batter way of thinking of it is how to do a second check when G240="EVO" is false. Remember the general format of an if statement is:
IF(CONDITION,True Result, False Result)
There are only 3 things that go into an if statement. you tried putting in 3.
Try rearranging to this:
=If($G240="EVO", Do True Condition, IF(SOME CHECK to determine DO FOMULA 1 or CHECK for G240 = FREE, Do Formula 1, IF(G$240=Free, Do Free True Condition, Do Free False Condition)))
Basically break down what you want to check for in G240 and do it in sequence with your IF statement. Right now with what you have written, I cant tell how you want to determine if you want to run your formula 1 or if you want to check if G240="free" since you have two different outcomes if G240="Free"/
OK I think i found the issue. The IF(AND(NOT(ISBLANK works on it's own since there are no other IFs in the formula. I do want to test two different cells for text(letters) in order to show a warning if one cell was blank while the other not. But as soon as you insert the (AND into a string of multiple IFs it doesn't work.
Simply removing the (AND was all I needed to do. Another way to achieve a test for more than one blank cell was to simply add multiple IF(ISBLANKs.
EG: =IF(ISBLANK(A1)+IF(ISBLANK(A2)>2;condition true;condition false)
ForwardEd thanks very much for your help!
Regards
I am trying to compare two data ranges to determine if they are the same or not.
I'm using the following statement and I get a #Value! error message:
=IF(SUM(ABS(B2:E7-G2:J7))=0,"Same", "Not")
If you are looking to see if the arithmetic total of the numbers in the two ranges is the same then this standard formula should do.
=IF(SUM(B2:E7)-SUM(G2:J7), "Not", "Same")
A zero in Excel evaluates to a boolean FALSE. Anything that is not false is TRUE.
This does not determine whether each cell directly corresponds to its 'sister' cell in the other range; only that the sum total of each is equal or not. The values in different cells could be interchanged or by coincidence be offset from one another in a perfect proportion to create an equal sum.
If you require a cell by cell analysis, then a much more complicated formula could be provided.
=IF(SUMPRODUCT(--(B2:E7=G2:J7))=24, "Same", "Not")
24 being the total number of cells in each range. While this does not require Ctrl+Shift+Enter, a SUMPRODUCT function does produce cyclic calculations.
Do you have strings in your answer or have the formula in row 1 or 8+? If yes that might be the reason as the formula works correctly assuming you
hit ctrl+shift+enter and
have only numbers in the ranges
For a general solution try
{=IF(AND(B2:E7=G2:J7),"Same","Not")}
Do not forget to hit ctrl+shift+enter as otherwise it will only look at the row the formula itself is in!