Can someone please clarify when to use API Manager and when to use Identity Server. I see that API Manager comes with Key Manager. Isn't that sufficient. I am really confused. Any help would be helpful.
Many thanks....
I hope this explaination will help you out,
WSO2 Identity Server
WSO2 Identity Server is a fully fledged Identity Management Solution which supports Authentication, Authorization, Single Sign-On and Identity Federation to name a few capabilities. WSO2 Identity Server supports almost all major identity protocols such as SAML, OAuth2, OpenID Connect etc.Take a look at this page to get an idea about the capabilities of WSO2 Identity Server.
WSO2 API Manager
WSO2 API Manager, on the other hand, focuses on managing your APIs. Managing life cycle of your APIs, Authorization, Throttling, applying policies on API consumers are some of the functionalities handled by API manager. API manager has several components such as publisher, store, gateway, key manager, traffic manager that clearly separates different aspects of API Management.
So the Key manager component is responsible for managing OAuth applications, generate, validate and revoke OAuth2 Tokens. API has an inbuilt key manager component to handle these functionalities.
API Manager also offers the flexibility to use an external key manager instead of its inbuilt one should you require to do so. This external key manager needs to confirm to an interface specified by API manager. By default, API has an implementation of this interface that allows WSO2 Identity Server to used an external key manager.
So whether or not you want to use Identity Server or any other external key manager is totally dependent on your use case and the API traffic.
You can use WSO2 Identity Server for all the authentication/authorization stuff:
XACML Architecture solution.
SSO with anothers webapps or WSO2 tools.
Implement a Oauth2 autorization mechanish
Federate authentication
etc....
You can uso WSO2 API Manager for expose unsecure resultful apis or webservices as secure apis using Oauth with monitoring and billings functionallities
The key manager functionallity properly decouples the operations for creating OAuth applications and validating access tokens so that you can even plug in a third party-authorization server for key validations.
In a DEV enviroment you can work with WSO2 API Manager without the WSO2 Identity Server at all.
In a production enviroment it's recommended to use a separate WSO2 API Manager as a Key Manager or use the WSO2 Identity Server as the Key Manager
Related
I wanted to do some POC for wso2 API manager where API Manager will expose login and registration url which will be called by UI layer but wanted to handle end user authorization and authentication
in API manager layer and don't want to handle this in database how can I do this i don't to use Identity server also.
I have gone through password grant_type tutorial and we can use this but how the authorization is going to performed?
Do we need to maintain user details in separate database or in identity server? if yes how this is going to happen.
I have gone through below questions but didn't get exact solution, please help me on this.
authorize user in wso2 api manager
wso2 api manager end-user
Thanks
how can I do this i don't to use Identity server also
By default you should be using the provided OAuth2 endpoints to authorize the users. However - the API Manager itselfs doesn't support self-registration and account verification.
I'd suggest to configure a WSO2 Identity Server as an APIM Key manager.
The WSO2IS has capability for self-registration and account verification.
The application or users will authenticate against the WSO2IS and the returned token will be valid for APIM (as the KeyManager shares the database with tokens).
Evaluating Wso2 API Manager. I have dozens of various APIs that have been developed by several groups over the past few years, all authenticate with IIS windows authentication.
How can I configure Wso2 API Manager to call a backend OData API that is expecting Windows Authentication in the request?
I don't actually need to pass-through authentication from the calling user, I'd be okay specifying a dedicated service account that API Manager always used to call the backend services.
API Manager supports NTLM authentication. You can follow the sample in APIM_HOME/samples/NTLMGrantClient. This documentation explains this. Also please follow this blog.
The Endpoint Auth Type "Windows Authentification" is not supported by API Manager. You might want to consider activating "Basic" or "Digest" authentification on your service in IIS (both of them are supported by API Manager).
see: https://docs.wso2.com/display/AM1100/Basic+Auth
I am trying to use wso2 identification server as authorization center:
there are several system, they share same user information
I want them to utilize identification server to perform authentication and authorization
In current research, I have found the API which I can use to perform authentication, and also soap api to perform user/group/permission management soap api
But I could not find the api which I can use to perform authorization request? So far those code are written in AuthrozationMgrJDBCImpl, there is no soap API expose those API.
Is there anybody know such API?
Yes.. WSO2 Identity Server can be used as centralized authorization management. There are two approaches
Use XACML capabilities of the WSO2IS. This is the standard way. WSO2IS can act as XACML PDP. You can create policies for different appolications. PDP is exposed as web service API, Application can call this web service API to receive authorization decision based on the policies. You can see the WSDL by pointing to https://localhost:9443/services/EntitlementService?wsdl. You can find more details on XACML and WSO2IS from here.
Use "AuthorizationAdminService" services. This is a custom way that you have referred. WSO2IS stores permission data in its own database and manage it through JDBCAuthorizationManager. However it only supports for RBAC. (in XACML you can use ABAC). you can see the WSDL by pointing to https://localhost:9443/services/AuthorizationAdminService?wsdl.
Note : You can see the WSDL of this service. But it is not exposed by default. Please go through this OS question. Also "AuthorizationAdminService" service available only after WSO2IS 450 version.
I was using OAuth for a REST API Service on WSO2-ESB using WSO2-IS, and now I wanted to register this service on API Manager. But looks like API Gateway already has OAuth incorporated.
Does it make sense to have WSO2-IS for OAuth in above scenario because having WSO2-API Manager and WSO2-IS make it a two layer OAuth which is not required?
Thanks,
Wajid
Yes API Gateway already has OAuth incorporated. WSO2 API Manager provides secure authorization for APIs using OAuth 2.0 standard for key management. Every API created through WSO2 APIM will engage authentication handler which does this. So if you are using WSO2 API Manger you can skip the engagement of OAuth to your REST API. If you want to keep your own authentication mechanism, it also can be done by defining your APIs in API Provider with None Auth type. In that case API gateway will just pass the any Authentication headers came in the request to the backend service, without validating. But here since you are also using OAuth, you can go with WSO2 API Manager's default authentication mechanism.
http://docs.wso2.org/wiki/display/AM131/API+Manager+Components
We want to connect WSO2 API Manager to WSO2 Identity server for application key management, so in other words we don't want to use the embedded key management that comes with API Manager, how can we achieve that?
IS is used as Oauth provider, but if we think about key management part, we have no of operations managed by APIM, to restrict /allow token accesses..
So, if you want to use IS as keymanagement server, you need to install APIM key-management related features in IS and in the api-mgt.xml,you have to provide IS server URL/credentials under APIKeymanagment section.