Regex: Repeat captured group [duplicate] - regex

Question

I need to capture multiple groups of the same pattern. Suppose, I have the following string:
HELLO,THERE,WORLD
And I've written the following pattern
^(?:([A-Z]+),?)+$
What I want it to do is to capture every single word, so that Group 1 is : "HELLO", Group 2 is "THERE" and Group 3 is "WORLD". What my regex is actually capturing is only the last one, which is "WORLD".
I'm testing my regular expression here and I want to use it with Swift (maybe there's a way in Swift to get intermediate results somehow, so that I can use them?)
UPDATE: I don't want to use split. I just need to now how to capture all the groups that match the pattern, not only the last one.

Answer 1

With one group in the pattern, you can only get one exact result in that group. If your capture group gets repeated by the pattern (you used the + quantifier on the surrounding non-capturing group), only the last value that matches it gets stored.
You have to use your language's regex implementation functions to find all matches of a pattern, then you would have to remove the anchors and the quantifier of the non-capturing group (and you could omit the non-capturing group itself as well).
Alternatively, expand your regex and let the pattern contain one capturing group per group you want to get in the result:
^([A-Z]+),([A-Z]+),([A-Z]+)$

Answer 2

The key distinction is repeating a captured group instead of capturing a repeated group.
As you have already found out, the difference is that repeating a captured group captures only the last iteration. Capturing a repeated group captures all iterations.
In PCRE (PHP):
((?:\w+)+),?
Match 1, Group 1. 0-5 HELLO
Match 2, Group 1. 6-11 THERE
Match 3, Group 1. 12-20 BRUTALLY
Match 4, Group 1. 21-26 CRUEL
Match 5, Group 1. 27-32 WORLD
Since all captures are in Group 1, you only need $1 for substitution.
I used the following general form of this regular expression:
((?:{{RE}})+)
Example at regex101

Answer 3

I think you need something like this....
b="HELLO,THERE,WORLD"
re.findall('[\w]+',b)
Which in Python3 will return
['HELLO', 'THERE', 'WORLD']

Answer 4

After reading Byte Commander's answer, I want to introduce a tiny possible improvement:
You can generate a regexp that will match either n words, as long as your n is predetermined. For instance, if I want to match between 1 and 3 words, the regexp:
^([A-Z]+)(?:,([A-Z]+))?(?:,([A-Z]+))?$
will match the next sentences, with one, two or three capturing groups.
HELLO,LITTLE,WORLD
HELLO,WORLD
HELLO
You can see a fully detailed explanation about this regular expression on Regex101.
As I said, it is pretty easy to generate this regexp for any groups you want using your favorite language. Since I'm not much of a swift guy, here's a ruby example:
def make_regexp(group_regexp, count: 3, delimiter: ",")
regexp_str = "^(#{group_regexp})"
(count - 1).times.each do
regexp_str += "(?:#{delimiter}(#{group_regexp}))?"
end
regexp_str += "$"
return regexp_str
end
puts make_regexp("[A-Z]+")
That being said, I'd suggest not using regular expression in that case, there are many other great tools from a simple split to some tokenization patterns depending on your needs. IMHO, a regular expression is not one of them. For instance in ruby I'd use something like str.split(",") or str.scan(/[A-Z]+/)

Answer 5

Just to provide additional example of paragraph 2 in the answer. I'm not sure how critical it is for you to get three groups in one match rather than three matches using one group. E.g., in groovy:
def subject = "HELLO,THERE,WORLD"
def pat = "([A-Z]+)"
def m = (subject =~ pat)
m.eachWithIndex{ g,i ->
println "Match #$i: ${g[1]}"
}
Match #0: HELLO
Match #1: THERE
Match #2: WORLD

Answer 6

The problem with the attempted code, as discussed, is that there is one capture group matching repeatedly so in the end only the last match can be kept.
Instead, instruct the regex to match (and capture) all pattern instances in the string, what can be done in any regex implementation (language). So come up with the regex pattern for this.
The defining property of the shown sample data is that the patterns of interest are separated by commas so we can match anything-but-a-comma, using a negated character class
[^,]+
and match (capture) globally, to get all matches in the string.
If your pattern need be more restrictive then adjust the exclusion list. For example, to capture words separated by any of the listed punctuation
[^,.!-]+
This extracts all words from hi,there-again!, without the punctuation. (The - itself should be given first or last in a character class, unless it's used in a range like a-z or 0-9.)
In Python
import re
string = "HELLO,THERE,WORLD"
pattern = r"([^,]+)"
matches = re.findall(pattern,string)
print(matches)
In Perl (and many other compatible systems)
use warnings;
use strict;
use feature 'say';
my $string = 'HELLO,THERE,WORLD';
my #matches = $string =~ /([^,]+)/g;
say "#matches";
(In this specific example the capturing () in fact aren't needed since we collect everything that is matched. But they don't hurt and in general they are needed.)
The approach above works as it stands for other patterns as well, including the one attempted in the question (as long as you remove the anchors which make it too specific). The most common one is to capture all words (usually meaning [a-zA-Z0-9_]), with the pattern \w+. Or, as in the question, get only the substrings of upper-case ascii letters[A-Z]+.

Answer 7

I know that my answer came late but it happens to me today and I solved it with the following approach:
^(([A-Z]+),)+([A-Z]+)$
So the first group (([A-Z]+),)+ will match all the repeated patterns except the final one ([A-Z]+) that will match the final one. and this will be dynamic no matter how many repeated groups in the string.

Answer 8

You actually have one capture group that will match multiple times. Not multiple capture groups.
javascript (js) solution:
let string = "HI,THERE,TOM";
let myRegexp = /([A-Z]+),?/g; // modify as you like
let match = myRegexp.exec(string); // js function, output described below
while (match != null) { // loops through matches
console.log(match[1]); // do whatever you want with each match
match = myRegexp.exec(string); // find next match
}
Syntax:
// matched text: match[0]
// match start: match.index
// capturing group n: match[n]
As you can see, this will work for any number of matches.

Answer 9

Sorry, not Swift, just a proof of concept in the closest language at hand.
// JavaScript POC. Output:
// Matches: ["GOODBYE","CRUEL","WORLD","IM","LEAVING","U","TODAY"]
let str = `GOODBYE,CRUEL,WORLD,IM,LEAVING,U,TODAY`
let matches = [];
function recurse(str, matches) {
let regex = /^((,?([A-Z]+))+)$/gm
let m
while ((m = regex.exec(str)) !== null) {
matches.unshift(m[3])
return str.replace(m[2], '')
}
return "bzzt!"
}
while ((str = recurse(str, matches)) != "bzzt!") ;
console.log("Matches: ", JSON.stringify(matches))
Note: If you were really going to use this, you would use the position of the match as given by the regex match function, not a string replace.

Answer 10

Design a regex that matches each particular element of the list rather then a list as a whole. Apply it with /g
Iterate throught the matches, cleaning them from any garbage such as list separators that got mixed in. You may require another regex, or you can get by with simple replace substring method.
The sample code is in JS, sorry :) The idea must be clear enough.
const string = 'HELLO,THERE,WORLD';
// First use following regex matches each of the list items separately:
const captureListElement = /^[^,]+|,\w+/g;
const matches = string.match(captureListElement);
// Some of the matches may include the separator, so we have to clean them:
const cleanMatches = matches.map(match => match.replace(',',''));
console.log(cleanMatches);

Answer 11

repeat the A-Z pattern in the group for the regular expression.
data="HELLO,THERE,WORLD"
pattern=r"([a-zA-Z]+)"
matches=re.findall(pattern,data)
print(matches)
output
['HELLO', 'THERE', 'WORLD']