c++ save class templated function pointer inside map - c++

Question

I'm having a small problem which I can't wrap my head around.
I have a function that looks like this:
template <typename T>
std::unique_ptr<Environment>& CreateEnvironment(sf::Vector2f& _position, bool _addToStatic = false);
This is my function pointer typedef
typedef std::unique_ptr<Environment>& (WorldEditor::*CreateEnvironmentPtr)(sf::Vector2f&, bool);
std::map<std::string,CreateEnvironmentPtr> listEnv;
And I'm trying to simply do this:
listEnv["test"] = &CreateEnvironment<Coin>(sf::Vector2f(200,200), false);
And i get the following error:
error C2440: '=' : cannot convert from 'std::unique_ptr<_Ty> *' to
'std::unique_ptr<_Ty> &(__thiscall WorldEditor::* )(sf::Vector2f
&,bool)'
I understand what the error is saying, but I don't know how to solve it. Also why does it even care about the return type when I'm pointing to the address of the function?
Best regards
nilo

Answer 1

problems such as these are often much better solved with std::function
std::map<std::string, std::function<void()> listEnv;
listEnv.emplace("test", [] {
CreateEnvironment<Coin>(sf::Vector2f(200,200), false);
});
to call:
listEnv.at("test")->second();

Answer 2

Based on your post I am not sure if you are attempting to create the member function pointer and map inside the CreateEnvironment class or outside of it, so I'll solve what I think is the more difficult problem of pointer to a separate object's member function.
I simplified your classes like so:
Environment
struct Environment
{
int i = 1;
};
Coin
struct Coin
{
int k = 0;
};
WorldEditor
struct WorldEditor
{
template <typename T>
std::unique_ptr<Environment> CreateEnvironment(int& _j, bool _addToStatic = false)
{
return std::make_unique<Environment>();
}
};
Solution: Map an object's member fn pointer, and then call it later
(I will be using C++11/14 syntax in my answer)
//declare a pointer to member function in WorldEditor
using CreateEnvironmentPtr = std::unique_ptr<Environment> (WorldEditor::*)(int&, bool);
//declare an object of type WorldEditor, because member function pointers need a "this" pointer
WorldEditor myWorldEditor;
int myInt = 42;
//map a string to the CreateEnvironment<Coin> function
std::map<std::string, CreateEnvironmentPtr> listEnv;
listEnv["test"] = &WorldEditor::CreateEnvironment<Coin>;
// call the member function pointer using the instance I created, as well as
// the mapped function
(myWorldEditor.*listEnv["test"])(myInt, false);
// (printing member value to cout to show it worked)
std::cout << (myWorldEditor.*listEnv["test"])(myInt, false)->i << std::endl; // prints 1
Live Demo
Solution 2: use std::bind and std::function
Perhaps we already know the parameters to the member function call at the time we create the entry for map. Using std::bind with a std::function will help us achieve that (Similar to Richard Hodges' solution):
// now our "function pointer" is really just a std::function that takes no arguments
using CreateEnvironmentPtr = std::function<std::unique_ptr<Environment>(void)>;
//declare an object of type WorldEditor, because member function pointers need a "this" pointer
WorldEditor myWorldEditor;
int myInt = 42;
//map a string to that function pointer
//ensure it gets called with the right args
// by using std::bind (which will also make the arg list appear the be void at call time)
// note that std::bind needs an instance of the class immediately after
// listing the function it should be binding
// only afterwards will we then pass the int& and bool
std::map<std::string, CreateEnvironmentPtr> listEnv;
listEnv["test"] = std::bind(&WorldEditor::CreateEnvironment<Coin>, &myWorldEditor, myInt, false);
// the mapped function
listEnv["test"]()->i;
// (printing resulting unique_ptr<Environment>'s member to cout to show it worked)
std::cout << listEnv["test"]()->i << std::endl; // prints 1
Live Demo 2