Function that does same things for different parameters - c++

Question

I have two functions that do the same thing: they add two numbers. One adds two numbers which are members of the class, the other adds numbers given by the user, outside the class.
Is there any way to write one single function that adds two numbers and checks whether the arguments are user input or class members?
void myclass::add(){
cout<<this->a+this->b;
}
void myclass::add(int a,int b){
cout<<a+b;
}

Answer 1

While you cannot really do it in a single function the common approach would be to write the more flexible of the two and use the other one just as a dispatcher:
void myclass::add(int a, int b) {
std::cout << (a+b);
}
void myclass::add() {
add(a,b);
}
Now, there are a different number of smells in this code... a function name reused to act on members or only inputs is one (a function that does not touch the object's state already smells at it not being a member, or being a static one). Printing inside a function called add (should it not return the values?)...

Answer 2

Disclaimer : I don't encourage such coding.
Ok, here's a method
void myClass::Add(int& a, int& b)
{
if (&a==&this->a)
{
std::cout << this->a + this->b
} else {
std::cout << a+b;
}
}
Ofc , things like myClass->Add(10,4) won't work... you will need some stack variables to hold the 10 and 4 variables.

Answer 3

So you want a single function that can have two different parameters? It isn't possible.
void myclass::add(int a, int b)
{
cout << a + b << endl;
}
Is what you want; but you can overload the function:
void myclass::add()
{
cout << memberA + memberB << endl;
}
In my opinion, this is a much better solution than having a single function that checks whether the variables are members or not; it makes your code readable. Don't be afraid to overload functions - it's one of those things that makes C++ awesome. I've created a class to demonstrate this:
class myClass
{
public:
myClass() : memberA(0), memberB(0) {}
~myClass() {}
void setNumbers(int a, int b)
{
memberA = a;
memberB = b;
}
void add(int a, int b)
{
cout << a + b << endl;
}
void add()
{
cout << memberA + memberB << endl;
}
private:
int memberA;
int memberB;
};
int main()
{
myClass m;
m.setNumbers(1, 2);
m.add();
return 0;
}
I've tested the add function with and without parameters and they both output the same result. The former because I used a setNumbers(..) function. Effectively, your first scenario of having two functions is the most apt solution to begin with.

Answer 4

In you realy wanted a single function, the way to do it is with optional default parameters.
Your declaration will be
void add(optional<int> a = optional<int>(), optional<int> b = optional<int>() );
Then in your implementation:
a ? a.get() : this->a
A benefit of this approach is that you can mix members and parameters. For example:
obj.add(1);
obj.add(optional<int>(), 2);