How to run record instruction-history and function-call-history in GDB? - gdb

Question

(EDIT: per the first answer below the current "trick" seems to be using an Atom processor. But I hope some gdb guru can answer if this is a fundamental limitation, or whether there adding support for other processors is on the roadmap?)
Reverse execution seems to be working in my environment: I can reverse-continue, see a plausible record log, and move around within it:
(gdb) start
...Temporary breakpoint 5 at 0x8048460: file bang.cpp, line 13.
Starting program: /home/thomasg/temp/./bang
Temporary breakpoint 5, main () at bang.cpp:13
13 f(1000);
(gdb) record
(gdb) continue
Continuing.
Breakpoint 3, f (d=900) at bang.cpp:5
5 if(d) {
(gdb) info record
Active record target: record-full
Record mode:
Lowest recorded instruction number is 1.
Highest recorded instruction number is 1005.
Log contains 1005 instructions.
Max logged instructions is 200000.
(gdb) reverse-continue
Continuing.
Breakpoint 3, f (d=901) at bang.cpp:5
5 if(d) {
(gdb) record goto end
Go forward to insn number 1005
#0 f (d=900) at bang.cpp:5
5 if(d) {
However the instruction and function histories aren't available:
(gdb) record instruction-history
You can't do that when your target is `record-full'
(gdb) record function-call-history
You can't do that when your target is `record-full'
And the only target type available is full, the other documented type "btrace" fails with "Target does not support branch tracing."
So quite possibly it just isn't supported for this target, but as it's a mainstream modern one (gdb 7.6.1-ubuntu, on amd64 Linux Mint "Petra" running an "Intel(R) Core(TM) i5-3570") I'm hoping that I've overlooked a crucial step or config?

Answer 1

It seems that there is no other solution except a CPU that supports it.
More precisely, your kernel has to support Intel Processor Tracing (Intel PT). This can be checked in Linux with:
grep intel_pt /proc/cpuinfo
See also: https://unix.stackexchange.com/questions/43539/what-do-the-flags-in-proc-cpuinfo-mean
The commands only works in record btrace mode.
In the GDB source commit beab5d9, it is nat/linux-btrace.c:kernel_supports_pt that checks if we can enter btrace. The following checks are carried out:
check if /sys/bus/event_source/devices/intel_pt/type exists and read the type
do a syscall (SYS_perf_event_open, &attr, child, -1, -1, 0); with the read type, and see if it returns >=0. TODO: why not use the C wrapper?
The first check fails for me: the file does not exist.
Kernel side
cd into the kernel 4.1 source and:
git grep '"intel_pt"'
we find arch/x86/kernel/cpu/perf_event_intel_pt.c which sets up that file. In particular, it does:
if (!test_cpu_cap(&boot_cpu_data, X86_FEATURE_INTEL_PT))
goto fail;
so intel_pt is a pre-requisite.
How I've found kernel_supports_pt
First grep for:
git grep 'Target does not support branch tracing.'
which leads us to btrace.c:btrace_enable. After a quick debug with:
gdb -q -ex start -ex 'b btrace_enable' -ex c --args /home/ciro/git/binutils-gdb/install/bin/gdb --batch -ex start -ex 'record btrace' ./hello_world.out
Virtual box does not support it either: Extract execution log from gdb record in a VirtualBox VM
Intel SDE
Intel SDE 7.21 already has this CPU feature, checked with:
./sde64 -- cpuid | grep 'Intel processor trace'
But I'm not sure if the Linux kernel can be run on it: https://superuser.com/questions/950992/how-to-run-the-linux-kernel-on-intel-software-development-emulator-sde
Other GDB methods
More generic questions, with less efficient software solutions:
call graph: List of all function calls made in an application
instruction trace: Displaying each assembly instruction executed in gdb

Answer 2

At least a partial answer (for the "am I doing it wrong" aspect) - from gdb-7.6.50.20140108/gdb/NEWS
* A new record target "record-btrace" has been added. The new target
uses hardware support to record the control-flow of a process. It
does not support replaying the execution, but it implements the
below new commands for investigating the recorded execution log.
This new recording method can be enabled using:
record btrace
The "record-btrace" target is only available on Intel Atom processors
and requires a Linux kernel 2.6.32 or later.
* Two new commands have been added for record/replay to give information
about the recorded execution without having to replay the execution.
The commands are only supported by "record btrace".
record instruction-history prints the execution history at
instruction granularity
record function-call-history prints the execution history at
function granularity
It's not often that I envy the owner of an Atom processor ;-)
I'll edit the question to refocus upon the question of workarounds or plans for future support.