I am rendering complex 3d objects. Here is a simple example with a sphere-like object:
Next I am applying a clipping plane to these objects and rendering a texture on this plane, giving the impression you are looking at the inside of the object, as if it was sliced. For example:
The problem is the jagged edge of the texture. It will stick out passed the boundary of the surface. Here's another angle where you can see it sticking out. The surface and the texture both derive from the same source data, but the surface is smoothed and has a higher resolution than the texture.
What I want is to be able to somehow clip the texture, so that it never sticks out past the boundary of the surface. Also, I don't want to simply scale down the texture, since although this might prevent it from sticking outside, it would create interior gaps between the texture edge and the surface edge. I would rather the texture be a little too big and have it clipped so that it sits flush against the edge of the surface.
Here's where I am:
I figured the first step would be to define the intersection of the plane and the surface. So now I have that, as an ordered list of line segments. However, I'm not sure how to proceed with this info (or if this is even the best approach).
I've been reading up on stencil buffers. One approach might be to turn the intersection line into a 2d shape and draw this into a stencil buffer. Then apply this when drawing the texture. (Although I think it's a lot of work since the shapes can be complicated.)
I am wondering if I can somehow use the already drawn surface (in conjunction with a stencil buffer or some other technique) to somehow clip the texture -- without having to go through the extra trouble of deriving the intersection line, etc.
What's the best approach here? (Any online examples you can point me to would also be really helpful.)
If you're clipping convex objects and know coordinates of clipped points, you can create polygonal "cap" yourself - just draw clipped points in proper order using GL_TRIANGLE_FAN, and that's it. Won't work with non-convex object - that would require triangulation algorithm. You could use glu tesselators to triangulate polygons, but that can be tricky/difficult.
If clipped area can be defined by formula, you can write a shader that'll precisely clip pixels over certain distance (i.e. if x^2+x^2+z^2 > r^2 do not draw pixel).
You could also draw back-facing faces with a shader that would draw every back facing pixel as if it were on on clip-plane using simple raytracing. That's complicated, and might be overkill in your case. Dead Rising used similar technique in their game engine.
Also you can use stencil buffer.
Draw back-facing faces first with GL_INCR (glStencilOp(GL_KEEP, GL_INCR, GL_INCR)), then draw front-facing surfaces with GL_DECR (glStencilOp(GL_KEEP, GL_DECR, GL_DECR)). Then draw texture only where stencil is non-zero. (glStencilFunc(GL_GREATER, 0, 0xff); glStencilOp(GL_KEEP, GL_KEEP, GL_KEEP);). If you have many overlapping shapes, however, you'll need to take special care of them.
--edit--
However, I'm not sure how to proceed with this info (or if this is even the best approach).
Draw it as a triangle fan. For convex objects, that's all you need. For non-convex objects that won't work.
ve been reading up on stencil buffers. One approach might be to turn the intersection line into a 2d shape
No, it won't work like that. Region you want to fill with texture should hold certain stencil value. That's how stencil clipping works.
to somehow clip the texture
In OpenGL you have 6(?) clip planes. If you need more than that, you'll need advanced techniques - stencil, deriving intersection line, shaders, or triangulation.
Any online examples you can point me to would also be really helpful
Drawing Filled, Concave Polygons Using the Stencil Buffer
Related
I want to draw shapes with holes in OpenGL and GLFW3. How can I do this? I don't want to use gluTessBeginPolygon.
this is a rectangle with a rectangle hole in it
If the shape is always the same, then the simplest way is to change how you visualize this. It's not a polygon with a hole, it's 2 (or more) polygons with no holes. Draw that instead:
However, if the shape changes dynamically, calculating this triangulation in code is difficult.
If you can't do this because the hole shape is dynamic then you can use the stencil buffer to prevent OpenGL from drawing where the hole is. Clear the stencil buffer, set the rendering mode so that you only write the stencil, then render the hole. Then set the modes back to normal but set the stencil test so it doesn't draw where the stencil buffer isn't zero, and render the rectangle. Then go back to normal.
If you have a shape with lots of holes (like a chain-link fence) then instead of rendering zillions of vertices, you should use a texture with an alpha channel, and use alpha testing in your shader - use discard; on the transparent pixels so they don't render. The fixed-function version of this is GL_ALPHA_TEST.
If you have a formula to detect whether a pixel is in the hole, you can use discard; as well. Your shader can discard for any reason you like - it doesn't have to be based on the alpha channel of a texture.
What you cannot do is count the number of times you cross the polygon boundary when going from left to right, like a scanline renderer might. That's because OpenGL processes all pixels in parallel - not left-to-right.
What's the best way to draw part of sphere in, for example, OpenGL, considering I have vertices of boundaries of region that should be rendered?
I'm drawing sphere using octahedron transformation (described here: https://stackoverflow.com/a/7687312/1840136) and I can draw arcs that represent boundaries in same way by creating intermediate vertices and then "normalizing" them.
To create triangles out of plane I can use something from this answer: https://math.stackexchange.com/a/1814637, but thing is it will be still flat something. To get part of sphere, I definitely need another bunch of intermediate vertices for additional triangles. What is the algorithms for such task? And, as I already may have triangles forming original sphere, can I use this data somehow?
I have a very simple case. I want to draw the outline of an object, in this case I think they'll only be spheres, but I'd like to not rely on this.
I've found methods such as:
Draw the object to the stencil buffer
Turn on wireframe mode
Draw the object with thick lines
Draw the real object on the top
The problem I have with this method is that my models have a lot of vertices, and this requires me to draw it three times. I'm getting some significant frame rate drops.
Are there other ways to do this? My next guess would be to draw circles on the final render as a post-process effect, seeing as I'm only looking at spheres. But I'd much much rather do this for more than just spheres.
Is there something I can do in an existing shader to outline?
I'd also like the outline to appear when the object is behind others.
I'm using OpenGL 4.3.
I know 3 ways of doing contour rendering:
Using the stencil buffer
The first one is a slightly modified version of the one you described: you first render your object as normal with stencil buffer on, then you slightly scale it and render it plain color where the stencil buffer is not filled. You can find an explanation of this technique here.
Using image processing techniques
The second one is a post-process step, where you look for edges using image processing filters (like the sobel operator) and you compose your rendering with your contour detection result. The good thing with the sobel operator is that it is separable; this means you can do the detection in two 1D passes, which is more efficient that doing one 2D pass.
Using the geometry shader
Last but not least, you can use the geometry shader to extract the silhouette of your mesh. The idea is to use adjacent vertices of a triangle to detect if one edge of this triangle (let call it t0) is a contour.
To do this, for each edge ei of t0:
build a new triangle ti using the vertices of ei and its associated vertex,
compute the normal ni of ti, and the normal n0 of t0, transform them both in view space (the silhouette depends on the point of view),
compute the dot product between n0 and ni. If its value is negative, this means that the normals are in opposite directions and the edge ei is a silhouette edge.
You then build a quad around ei, emit each of its vertices and color them the way you want in the fragment shader.
This is the basic idea of this algorithm. Using only this will result in aliased edges, with holes between them, but this can be improved. You can read this paper, and this blog post for further informations.
In my experience you get good results if you render the outlined object in white (unlit) to a texture as big as the final framebuffer, then draw a framebuffer-sized quad with that texture and have the fragment shader blur or otherwise process it and apply the desired color.
I have an example here
I'm hoping to draw a plane in OpenGL, using C++, with a hole in the center, much like the green of a golf course for example.
I was wondering what the easiest way to achieve this is?
It's fairly simple to draw a circle and a plane (tutorials all over google will show this for those curious), but I was wondering if there is a boolean subtraction technique like you can get when modelling in 3Ds Max or similar software? Where you create both objects, then take the intersection/union etc to leave a new object/shape? In this case subtract the circle from the plane, creating a hole.
Another way I thought of doing it is giving the circle alpha values and making it transparent, but then of course it still leaves the planes surface visible anyway.
Any help or points in the right direction?
I would avoid messing around with transparency, blending mode, and the like. Just create a mesh with the shape you need and draw it. Remember OpenGL is for graphics, not modelling.
There are a couple ways you could do this. The first way is the one you already stated which is to draw the circle as transparent. The caveat is that you must draw the circle first before you draw the plane so that the alpha blending will blend the circle with the background. Then when you render the plane the parts that are covered by the circle will be discarded in the depth test.
The second method you could try is with texture mapping. You could create a texture that is basically a mask with everything set to opaque white except the circle portion which is set to have an alpha value of 0. In your shader you would then multiply your fragment color by this mask texture color so that the portions where the circle is located are now transparent.
Both of these methods would work with shapes other than a circle as well.
I suggest the stencil buffer. Use the stencil buffer to mark the area where you want the hole to be by masking the color and depth buffers and drawing only to the stencil buffer, then unmask your color and depth, avoid drawing to the stencil buffer, and draw your plane with a stencil function telling OpenGL to discard all pixels where the stencil buffer "markings" are.
I'm going to have meshes with several coplanar polygons, all lying in a certain plane, that I'm not going to be able to eliminate.
These polygons have a specific draw order. Some polygons are behind other polygons. If I turn off depth testing I'll have the effect I want, but I want to be able to position this mesh in a 3D scene.
I do not trust glPolygonOffset because I'll potentially have several of these overlapping polygons and am am worried about the cumulative effects of the offset.
If I turn off depth testing I'll have the effect I want, but I want to be able to position this mesh in a 3D scene.
Simply disable writing to z-buffer, without disabling depth test.
glDepthMask(GL_FALSE);
Make sure to render all polygons that doesn't require glDepthMask(GL_FALSE) before rendering any polygons with glDepthMask(GL_FALSE); Otherwise object will be incorrectly positioned.
If you can't do that, then you should change your geometry or use texture instead.
glDepthMask documentation