How to use an XSL variable as a condition to evaluate XPath? - xslt

Question

I have faced an issue when using a variable as a condition for XPath evaluation. I have the following template which works fine:
<xsl:template name="typeReasonDic">
<xsl:variable name="dic" select="$schema//xs:simpleType[#name = 'type_reason_et']"/>
<!-- do something with the variable -->
</xsl:template>
However, when I change it to look like this:
<xsl:template name="typeReasonDic">
<xsl:param name="choose_dic" select="#name = 'type_reason_et'"/>
<xsl:variable name="dic" select="$schema//xs:simpleType[$choose_dic]"/>
<!-- do something with the variable -->
</xsl:template>
it fails to find the desired node.
What I wish to get is a template with a default value for $choose_dic which can be overriden where necessary.
What am I missing here?
UPD: there is this link I found with the description of what I'm trying to do, but it doesn't seem to work for me.

Answer 1

You can't do this directly in XSLT 1.0 or 2.0 without an extension function. The problem is that with
<xsl:template name="typeReasonDic">
<xsl:param name="choose_dic" select="#name = 'type_reason_et'"/>
<xsl:variable name="dic" select="$schema//xs:simpleType[$choose_dic]"/>
<!-- do something with the variable -->
</xsl:template>
the <xsl:param> will evaluate its select expression a single time in the current context and store the true/false result of this evaluation in the $choose_dic variable. The <xsl:variable> will therefore select either all xs:simpleType elements under the $schema (if $choose_dic is true) or none of them (if $choose_dic) is false. This is very different from
<xsl:variable name="dic" select="$schema//xs:simpleType[#name = 'type_reason_et']"/>
which will evaluate #name = 'type_reason_et' repeatedly, in the context of each xsl:simpleType, and select those elements for which the expression evaluated to true.
If you store the XPath expression as a string you can use an extension function such as dyn:evaluate or the XSLT 3.0 xsl:evaluate element if you're using Saxon.

Answer 2

By doing
<xsl:param name="choose_dic" select="#name = 'type_reason_et'"/>
the XSL engine will try to evaluate "#name = 'type_reason_et'" as an XPath expression, and will assign the RESULT to your variable.
You should use the following variable declaration instead:
<xsl:param name="choose_dic">#name = 'type_reason_et'</xsl:param>
This is the default value, but you can override it when you call your template by using xsl:with-param.

Answer 3

XSLT is not a macro language where you might be able to concatenate your code at run-time from strings and then evaluate them dynamically. So in general for your purpose you would need an extension function to evaluate an XPath expression stored in a string or you need to look into a new XSLT 3.0 features like http://www.saxonica.com/documentation/xsl-elements/evaluate.xml.
What is possible in the scope of XSLT 1.0 or 2.0 is doing e.g.
<xsl:param name="p1" select="'foo'"/>
<xsl:variable name="v1" select="//bar[#att = $p1]"/>
where the param holds a value you compare to other value, for instance those in a node like an attribute or element node.