COM interop: how to use ICustomMarshaler to call 3rd party component - c++

Question

I want to call a method in a COM component from C# using COM interop. This is the methods signature:
long GetPrecursorInfoFromScanNum(long nScanNumber,
LPVARIANT pvarPrecursorInfos,
LPLONG pnArraySize)
and this is sample code (which I checked is really working) to call it in C++:
struct PrecursorInfo
{
double dIsolationMass;
double dMonoIsoMass;
long nChargeState;
long nScanNumber;
};
void CTestOCXDlg::OnOpenParentScansOcx()
{
VARIANT vPrecursorInfos;
VariantInit(&vPrecursorInfos);
long nPrecursorInfos = 0;
m_Rawfile.GetPrecursorInfoFromScanNum(m_nScanNumber,
&vPrecursorInfos,
&nPrecursorInfos);
// Access the safearray buffer
BYTE* pData;
SafeArrayAccessData(vPrecursorInfos.parray, (void**)&pData);
for (int i=0; i < nPrecursorInfos; ++i)
{
// Copy the scan information from the safearray buffer
PrecursorInfo info;
memcpy(&info,
pData + i * sizeof(MS_PrecursorInfo),
sizeof(PrecursorInfo));
}
SafeArrayUnaccessData(vPrecursorInfos.parray);
}
And here's the corresponding C# signature after importing the typelib of the COM component:
void GetPrecursorInfoFromScanNum(int nScanNumber, ref object pvarPrecursorInfos, ref int pnArraySize);
If I'm not mistaken, I need to pass in null for pvarPrecursorInfos to make COM interop marshal it as the expected VT_EMPTY variant. When I'm doing it, I get a SafeArrayTypeMismatchException - not really surprising, looking at how the result is expected to be handled in the sample. So I was trying to use a custom marshaler. Since a cannot alter the component itself, I tried to introduce it this way:
[Guid("06F53853-E43C-4F30-9E5F-D1B3668F0C3C")]
[TypeLibType(4160)]
[ComImport]
public interface IInterfaceNew : IInterfaceOrig
{
[DispId(130)]
int GetPrecursorInfoFromScanNum(int nScanNumber, [MarshalAs(UnmanagedType.CustomMarshaler, MarshalTypeRef = typeof(MyMarshaler))] ref object pvarPrecursorInfos, ref int pnArraySize);
}
The TypeLibType and DispID attribute are the same as in the original version. This works as far as that the MyMarshaller.GetInstance() method is called, but I do not get a callback in MyMarshaller.NativeToManaged. Instead, an access violation is reported. So is this a reliable approach? If yes - how can I make it work? If no: are there any alternatives?
(Just a footnote: in theory I could try to use managed C++ to call the component natively. However, there are lots of other methods in it that work fine with COM interop, so I would very much like to stick with C# if there is any way.)

Answer 1

Since someone asked for it, here's my solution in Managed C++.
array<PrecursorInfo^>^ MSFileReaderExt::GetPrecursorInfo(int scanNumber)
{
VARIANT vPrecursorInfos;
VariantInit(&vPrecursorInfos);
long nPrecursorInfos = -1;
//call the COM component
long rc = pRawFile->GetPrecursorInfoFromScanNum(scanNumber, &vPrecursorInfos, &nPrecursorInfos);
//read the result
//vPrecursorInfos.parray points to a byte sequence
//that can be seen as array of MS_PrecursorInfo instances
//(MS_PrecursorInfo is a struct defined within the COM component)
MS_PrecursorInfo* pPrecursors;
SafeArrayAccessData(vPrecursorInfos.parray, (void**)&pPrecursors);
//now transform into a .NET object
array<PrecursorInfo^>^ infos = gcnew array<PrecursorInfo^>(nPrecursorInfos);
MS_PrecursorInfo currentPrecursor;
for (int i=0; i < nPrecursorInfos; ++i)
{
currentPrecursor = pPrecursors[i];
infos[i] = safe_cast<PrecursorInfo^>(Marshal::PtrToStructure(IntPtr(&currentPrecursor), PrecursorInfo::typeid));
}
SafeArrayUnaccessData(vPrecursorInfos.parray);
return infos;
}

Answer 2

I look at the github code mzLib, which I believe is related to this topic. The code looks good, where it calls
pin_ptr<const wchar_t> wch = PtrToStringChars(path);
I think it may cause some problem, better use
pin_ptr<const wchar_t> pathChar = static_cast<wchar_t*>(System::Runtime::InteropServices::Marshal::StringToHGlobalUni(path).ToPointer());
The code then seems to be worked just fine when compiles. However, it might run in problem when imported as dll. I worked on that by adding a constructor,such as
public ref class ThermoDLLClass
{
public:
ThermoDLLClass();
PrecursorInfo GetPrecursorInfo(int scanNum, String^ path);
};
Then, it seems to get precursorInfo and parameters appropriately.