Inline Form Validation in Django - django

Question

I would like to make an entire inline formset within an admin change form compulsory. So in my current scenario when I hit save on an Invoice form (in Admin) the inline Order form is blank. I'd like to stop people creating invoices with no orders associated.
Anyone know an easy way to do that?
Normal validation like (required=True) on the model field doesn't appear to work in this instance.

Answer 1

The best way to do this is to define a custom formset, with a clean method that validates that at least one invoice order exists.
class InvoiceOrderInlineFormset(forms.models.BaseInlineFormSet):
def clean(self):
# get forms that actually have valid data
count = 0
for form in self.forms:
try:
if form.cleaned_data:
count += 1
except AttributeError:
# annoyingly, if a subform is invalid Django explicity raises
# an AttributeError for cleaned_data
pass
if count < 1:
raise forms.ValidationError('You must have at least one order')
class InvoiceOrderInline(admin.StackedInline):
formset = InvoiceOrderInlineFormset
class InvoiceAdmin(admin.ModelAdmin):
inlines = [InvoiceOrderInline]

Answer 2

Daniel's answer is excellent and it worked for me on one project, but then I realized due to the way Django forms work, if you are using can_delete and check the delete box while saving, it's possible to validate w/o any orders (in this case).
I spent a while trying to figure out how to prevent that from happening. The first situation was easy - don't include the forms that are going to get deleted in the count. The second situation was trickier...if all the delete boxes are checked, then clean wasn't being called.
The code isn't exactly straightforward, unfortunately. The clean method is called from full_clean which is called when the error property is accessed. This property is not accessed when a subform is being deleted, so full_clean is never called. I'm no Django expert, so this might be a terrible way of doing it, but it seems to work.
Here's the modified class:
class InvoiceOrderInlineFormset(forms.models.BaseInlineFormSet):
def is_valid(self):
return super(InvoiceOrderInlineFormset, self).is_valid() and \
not any([bool(e) for e in self.errors])
def clean(self):
# get forms that actually have valid data
count = 0
for form in self.forms:
try:
if form.cleaned_data and not form.cleaned_data.get('DELETE', False):
count += 1
except AttributeError:
# annoyingly, if a subform is invalid Django explicity raises
# an AttributeError for cleaned_data
pass
if count < 1:
raise forms.ValidationError('You must have at least one order')

Answer 3

class MandatoryInlineFormSet(BaseInlineFormSet):
def is_valid(self):
return super(MandatoryInlineFormSet, self).is_valid() and \
not any([bool(e) for e in self.errors])
def clean(self):
# get forms that actually have valid data
count = 0
for form in self.forms:
try:
if form.cleaned_data and not form.cleaned_data.get('DELETE', False):
count += 1
except AttributeError:
# annoyingly, if a subform is invalid Django explicity raises
# an AttributeError for cleaned_data
pass
if count < 1:
raise forms.ValidationError('You must have at least one of these.')
class MandatoryTabularInline(admin.TabularInline):
formset = MandatoryInlineFormSet
class MandatoryStackedInline(admin.StackedInline):
formset = MandatoryInlineFormSet
class CommentInlineFormSet( MandatoryInlineFormSet ):
def clean_rating(self,form):
"""
rating must be 0..5 by .5 increments
"""
rating = float( form.cleaned_data['rating'] )
if rating < 0 or rating > 5:
raise ValidationError("rating must be between 0-5")
if ( rating / 0.5 ) != int( rating / 0.5 ):
raise ValidationError("rating must have .0 or .5 decimal")
def clean( self ):
super(CommentInlineFormSet, self).clean()
for form in self.forms:
self.clean_rating(form)
class CommentInline( MandatoryTabularInline ):
formset = CommentInlineFormSet
model = Comment
extra = 1

Answer 4

#Daniel Roseman solution is fine but i have some modification with some less code to do this same.
class RequiredFormSet(forms.models.BaseInlineFormSet):
def __init__(self, *args, **kwargs):
super(RequiredFormSet, self).__init__(*args, **kwargs)
self.forms[0].empty_permitted = False
class InvoiceOrderInline(admin.StackedInline):
model = InvoiceOrder
formset = RequiredFormSet
class InvoiceAdmin(admin.ModelAdmin):
inlines = [InvoiceOrderInline]
try this it also works :)

Answer 5

The situation became a little bit better but still needs some work around. Django provides validate_min and min_num attributes nowadays, and if min_num is taken from Inline during formset instantiation, validate_min can be only passed as init formset argument. So my solution looks something like this:
class MinValidatedInlineMixIn:
validate_min = True
def get_formset(self, *args, **kwargs):
return super().get_formset(validate_min=self.validate_min, *args, **kwargs)
class InvoiceOrderInline(MinValidatedInlineMixIn, admin.StackedInline):
model = InvoiceOrder
min_num = 1
validate_min = True
class InvoiceAdmin(admin.ModelAdmin):
inlines = [InvoiceOrderInline]