linux pseudo terminal (open select read) - c++

Question

I have a following scenario: Someone creates a pseudo terminal via opening /dev/ptmx. New terminal is created and named for example /dev/pts/2. Then, in my program I open /dev/pts/2 for reading. But I also open other devices for reading and use select() function to wait for any incoming data. The select have also some timeout specified for performing other stuff when no data arrives for too long. After successful select i read data using read() function and then print it on the screen.
I encountered an issue if the pseudo terminal is closed by the one who created it. In this case select function ends immediately indicating success as well as read ends indicating "no data" by returning zero. The issue imho is that neither select nor read returns error in such case. How should I handle this to detect that the terminal is no longer existing?
Status processData()
{
fd_set readFileDescriptorSet; // defined somewhere else
int maxFileDescriptor; // defined somewhere else
struct timeval timeout; // defined somewhere else
int ret = select(maxFileDescriptor + 1, &readFileDescriptorSet, nullptr, nullptr, &timeout);
if (!ret) // timeout
return Status::success();
if (ret < 0) // error from select()
return Status::error("select error");
ssize_t rd;
char buff[10];
do {
rd = read(interfaces.serialPort.getFileDescriptor(), buff, sizeof(buff) - 1);
if (rd > 0) { // some data has been read
buff[rd] = '\0';
std::cout << buff;
}
} while (rd > 0);
if (rd < 0) // error from read()
return Status::error("read error");
return Status::success();
}
While the way I open the pseudo terminal is following:
Status internalOpen(std::string fileName)
{
close();
fileDescriptor = ::open(fileName.c_str(), O_RDWR | O_NOCTTY | O_NONBLOCK);
if (fileDescriptor == -1)
return Status::error("Terminal::internalOpen::open('" + fileName + "')");
struct termios attributes;
if (tcgetattr(fileDescriptor, &attributes))
return Status::error("Terminal::internalOpen::tcgetattr()");
setAttributes(attributes);
if (tcsetattr(fileDescriptor, TCSANOW, &attributes))
return Status::error("Terminal::internalOpen::tcsetattr()");
return Status::success();
}
void setAttributes(struct termios &attributes)
{
cfmakeraw(&attributes);
cfsetspeed(&attributes, Config::baudRate);
attributes.c_iflag &= ~(IXOFF | IXANY);
attributes.c_oflag &= ~(ONLCR);
attributes.c_lflag &= ~(ECHOE);
attributes.c_cflag &= ~(CSTOPB | CRTSCTS);
attributes.c_cflag |= CREAD | CLOCAL;
attributes.c_cc[VMIN] = 0;
attributes.c_cc[VTIME] = 0;
}

Answer 1

After select() returns indicating that there's something to be read, the shown code loops repeatedly trying to read() from the non-blocking file descriptor until it is 0:
do {
rd = read( ...
} while (rd > 0);
That's certainly reasonable. Except that the closed connection results in the very first read() returning 0, which the shown logic cannot discriminate.
All that's really needed here is to keep track of whether anything has been read, prior read() returning 0. But if read() returned 0 right off the bat, your goose is cooked.
Additionally, there a few other improvements will make things more robust.
After select() returns, actually check if the file descriptor's bit remains set in the readFileDescriptorSet. The shown logic simply assumes that it is, by checking for all other possibilities. Still, this is somewhat fragile. It's easy to forget this assumption if something tangentially related gets modified (i.e., another fle descriptor gets thrown into the mix).
Use poll() instead of select(), and explicitly check for POLLHUP|POLLRDHUP in revents. The file descriptor closure condition is more explicitly called out, in the poll() interface.